
I, like others, picked up Weinberg's book after the stellar Nochlin review. I was somewhat puzzled by the project at first, but as is often the case with the art Weinberg discusses, "Ambition and Love in Modern American Art" is too seductive to dismiss. While his categories seem vague, even silly, his discussion of the artists and their work is elegant. His style is always engaging, mostly because it is so often personal. I suspect that critics have been troubled by Weinberg's approach, the lack of any real scholarly investigation, replaced by coffee-table talk and emotional musings. I can't really refute such critiques. But I do think that Weinberg's approach holds a lesson for all those interested in studying, writing about, and even practicing art. To try and separate oneself from the art you create or examine is a futile enteprise. His inclusion and discussion of such themes (God forbid!) as love, desire, and ambition adds a much needed jolt of blood and flesh into art history. It reminds us that art history is no science and that art historians need not feel so insecure about that. After all, art-making itself is not just a process of intellect, it is one of passion. Perhaps historians should investigate their own stirrings a bit more, as Weinberg has done here, to make their own scholarship truly insightful and what's more, readable.
Average Rating:

Author: Mr. Jonathan Weinberg
ISBN: 0300081871
Number Of Pages: 328
Languages:
Original Language: English
Unknown: English
Published: English
Product Description:Sigmund Freud wrote that the artist "desires to win honor, power, wealth, fame, and the love of women." In this engrossing book, Jonathan Weinberg investigates how an artist's ambition interacts with his or her art, how wealth and celebrity play a role in the artistic process. He shows that anxiety about the relationship of an artwork to identity and the corrupting influence of fame plague modern artists of all genders and sexual orientations. Weinberg explores eccentric acts in the artistic careers of Jean-Michel Basquiat, Walker Evans, David Hockney, Sally Mann, Georgia O'Keeffe, Jackson Pollock, Alfred Stieglitz, Andy Warhol, and others, through which these artists struggle to gain or maintain the attention of an increasingly jaded audience.
Weinberg begins by discussing Whistler's famous portrait of his mother in terms of maternal metaphors for painting. He follows with a discussion of the familial relationships forged by artists like Pollock and Mann with their imagined tradition. He next focuses on the role of love in photographs by Stieglitz as well as O'Keeffe's attempts to find autonomy from the overwhelming attention of her partner Stieglitz. Weinberg also reveals that artistic fame is usually a matter of competition, and he examines the impulse of artists like James Agee and Evans and Basquiat and Warhol to work together. The book concludes with a rumination on the NAMES Project Quilt and the problem of what becomes of those who die in obscurity.
Available at Amazon
List Price: USD 45.00
Lowest Used Price: USD 5.27
Lowest New Price: USD 24.00

Customer Reviews

Thought-provoking, compassionate, and erudite
I absolutely love this book, esp. the chapters on Bourke-White et al, and on Warhol and Basquiat. I agree with previous reviewers that this is a book full of soul by a writer and artist who loves and understands the creative process. This is a great text to teach with my upper-level undergraduates. I highly recommend it even for those only mindly interested in art, as an erudite page-turner that will make you think.

A Perfect Antidote to the Myth of the Pure Genius
This is one of the best art history reads I've had in a long time. Wenberg's is an original mind. You just have to try it for yourself.

A must for scholars of American art!
Picked up this book based on Linda Nochlin's rave review in Art in America, and also, having recently heard Weinberg speak in New Mexico. This is a smart well-written text which will appeal to scholars and regular folks as well. Chapter on O'Keeffe, and the one on O'Keeffe and Stieglitz quite fascinating, as is the Weinberg's take on Agee and Evans. I plan on assigning this to my students for a course on 20th century American art.

Purchase this Book! Incredibly Absorptive...
I loved this book. This magisterial work makes for absorptive reading- it absorbs your interest in art as well as your capacity to read further. The author displays an incredible sponge-like capacity. Like a sponge used to prevent any conception, the work keeps anything from coming into mind. I particularly loved the chapters on Wharhole and Polyp: Weineberg's own style pays fantastic homage in imitating the abrasive contents of the former's brillo box. It's also great how the author just soaks up some cast off comments from Freud and Manzoni, draining them like a vampire. He just sinks his teeth right in! I had a few disagreements about how he handled Basquiat with rubber gloves, especially the early work, but in the end I appreciated Weinberg's janitorial finesse and the range of his sweeping generalization.